How do I judge a trade in one move?
Add what you lose, add what you gain, compare the two totals.
When a capture sequence starts, list every piece that leaves the board on each side. Sum the values on your side, sum the values on theirs, and subtract. A bishop (3) traded for a rook (5) wins two points of material before any positional factor is considered.
Equal totals do not always mean an equal trade. Two minor pieces (6 points) are generally stronger than a rook plus a pawn (also 6 points), because the two pieces cover more squares and coordinate. A queen at 9 points against two rooks at 10 points is usually good for the two rooks, though exceptions exist when the queen has a forced attack.
After the arithmetic, ask two questions: does the resulting position give me a concrete tactic, and does my opponent get a tempo back? Points are the first filter, not the last word.
- Write down both sides of the trade as a sum.
- Subtract the smaller total from the larger.
- Check whether equal points hide a structural difference.
- Look for a follow-up tactic before you commit.